Railroaded: A Eulogy for Public Input by Robert M. Brantley


Scoop

By admin, Section Brantley in The News
Posted on Thu Feb 16, 2006 at 09:19:20 AM EST

Robert M. Brantley (right) makes a impassioned statement about public input at a protest over the closing of the railroad crossing at Broadway Avenue. (Photo by Christina Dicken / News-Leader)Photo By: Christena Dicken of the Springfield News-Leader

Public Input

Local lore has it that public input was born in Springfield when the name of our fair city was chosen from a list of names submitted by future community members.

Public input thrived as we saw the incorporation of our queen city on February 18, 1838. And public input was reinforced in 1887 when Springfield and North Springfield voted to merge and become one.

But since that time, the health of Public input has experienced a severe turn for the worse.

When neighbors in Rountree decried the re-zoning of property that would only serve the self-interest of a few they were ignored. The health of public input took a setback.

When our Friends who serve as police officers and fire fighters asked for and got approved by the voters a workable pension plan, the health of public input was degraded through the total disregard of what was expressed at the ballot box.

When multiple issues are combined on a single ballot, like schools and crime labs, public input is again weakened because a vote for or against one proposition is not necessarily a vote for or against another. It is impossible to tell what the public input is under such convoluted terms. Public Input is drowning.

When Springfield's voters call for a serious look at Energy Conservation as well as increased energy production, Public Input was again struck down and pushed aside in what appears to be predetermined outcomes.

Public Input, after having been railroaded right here at the Broadway Crossing, appears to be in it final throes. After repeatedly being ignored, struck down, chastised... public input may be dead.

Neighbors question the purpose of spending time and energy providing input when they know it will be ignored. Voters become apathetic saying `my vote doesn't count' and believe it to be true because in the past it has rung true.

But even with the gloom and doom as I look around me I start to question if public input has truly died or is just beginning to come back alive.

As I look around I see neighbors standing beside other neighbors as a block, over common issues of common concern. I see political players from all sides of the aisle setting aside those extreme issues that divide us and working on the common ground that unites us. I see families standing with and supporting other families they barely know.

It's not a death, I think, but instead a birth. It's not a funeral, I feel, but a celebration.

Public Input is not dead. It's right here and it's right now. Public Input is what we make of it and we're making the best of it here at the Historical Broadway Crossing today.  

Public Input lives.

-------

Robert Brantley delivered this Eulogy on February 15, 2006 at the Closing Ceremonies of the Historic Broadway Crossing in Northwest Springfield Missouri.

< TRICARE Rate Hikes | Act locally with instant runoff voting: >

Login

Make a new account

Username:
Password:

Related Links

+
+ More on Scoop
+ Also by admin

Display: Sort:
Railroaded: A Eulogy for Public Input by Robert M. Brantley | 5 comments (5 topical, 0 hidden)
Julie Sigloch also Delivered a Great Speech (none / 0) (#1)
by admin on Thu Feb 16, 2006 at 10:42:53 AM EST

Julie Sigloch also delivered a great speech on behalf of the Grant Beach Neighborhood Association. 

She quoted from 1986 Noble Peace Prize winner Elie Wiesel's view on indifference as applied to our situation in Springfield.



From The Springfield News-Leader (none / 0) (#2)
by admin on Thu Feb 16, 2006 at 10:47:46 AM EST

Residents lament city's closing of rail crossing: Neighbors seek council's attention by staging funeral for "Public Input."

by Amos Bridges, News-Leader 

Call it a publicity stunt, call it public input. Residents of two north-side neighborhoods staged a mock funeral Tuesday at the defunct Broadway Avenue railroad crossing to remind city officials of their displeasure -- and their presence.

At the request of Burlington Northern Santa Fe, Springfield's City Council voted 6-2 on Dec. 12 to close the crossing, which offered north-south access between Chase and Commercial streets.

The change was widely opposed by residents of the Grant Beach and Woodland Heights neighborhoods, who said closure could split their neighborhoods and create additional safety hazards when traffic was re- routed to the aging Grant Avenue underpass nearby.

About 20 of them, many wearing black arm bands, gathered south of the crossing Tuesday evening near a miniature coffin and headstone that read, "RIP Public Input."

"Neighbors question the purpose of spending time and energy providing input when they know it will be ignored," Robert Brantley said as he read from a eulogy composed for the occasion.

All was not doom and gloom, however -- "Public Input" had been reborn by the funeral's end.

....

Those gathered Wednesday also vowed to make themselves heard at the ballot box.

"Everybody is aware of Broadway now," Brantley said, explaining neighbors renewed drive to political activity. "So I think it's going to become a rallying cry."

Source



From KOLR10: Neighbors Mourn Loss (none / 0) (#3)
by admin on Thu Feb 16, 2006 at 11:07:56 AM EST

Neighbors "Mourn" Lost Fight Over Rail Crossing 

Neighbors of the Grant Beach and Woodland Heights Neighborhoods held a ceremony Wednesday evening - a mock funeral - to mark a lost battle over keeping a railroad crossing open. 

Neighbors are saying the "funeral" is a way to put their failed effort to keep the crossing near Broadway and Commercial open to vehicle traffic, and focus on the future.

Trains are rolling through on the tracks with dead ends on either side of the street. People now see the roadblocks as symbolic for the obstacles they faced in this battle, specifically their concerns about safety.

The City of Springfield was responsible for removing the pavement leading to the tracks on Broadway and putting up guardrails.

Burlington Northern-Sante Fe Railroad is tasked with putting up fencing at the crossing, but those fences were yet not in place by late Wednesday.

Citizens and city leaders also are still evaluating what this means for traffic east and west of this closing. 

Although the City Council voted to close the intersection, members promised to evaluate the decision and monitor safety in the area. 

While neighbors say they were sold out for development plans in the West Meadows area, the move is fueling local activism.

"It`s a done deal," admits Julie Sigloch, a member of the Grant Beach Neighborhood Association. "The road is torn up, the fences are going up. Now we want to make sure our voices are heard in the future and other neighborhood`s voices are heard as well."

Council member Mary Collette says the Council did listen to neighbors before taking action to close the crossing. "It`s not that they weren`t heard, it`s that they were outvoted," Collette said. "It`s sad they had this loss for the good of the larger community."

BNSF paid the city $65,000 for the closing. Neighbors in the area are working on a beautification plan or other uses for that money. 

But residents also say the dead end drives them to seek other changes. They`re committed to holding the city to promises about protecting safety in the area."There was anger but now it`s trying to push people to be involved, get them to register to vote," Sigloch said. 

There was concern about what the closing at Broadway and Commercial would mean for traffic at the Grant Street overpass just north of Commercial. 

Several large trucks have gotten stuck under the low overhang in recent months. And neighbors say foot and auto traffic at Grant will become more dangerous with Broadway`s closing. Collette says the crossing could be positive for development at the overpass. 

Source



We Should Commend Councilman Denny Whayne (none / 0) (#5)
by Rob on Thu Feb 16, 2006 at 11:22:33 AM EST

Robert M. Brantley and Denny Whayne walk and talk before the Official Closing Ceremony of the Historic Broadway Crossing in Springfield. (Photo by Richard Napieralski)I think we should Commend Councilman Denny Whayne, who represents Zone 1 on Springfield City Council, for his courage to vote for and with the residents of Northwest Springfield and his courage in coming to this event. 

Whayne was the only Springfield City Council member to show up for the Official Closing Ceremony of the Historic Broadway Crossing in Springfield.

 

 



Public Input Keeps Rearing its Ugly Head! (none / 0) (#7)
by admin on Mon Feb 27, 2006 at 11:36:47 AM EST

On the same day that the Springfield News-Leader covered the burial, they ran an online poll asking:

"Do you think city administrators and elected officials listen to public comment on local issues?"

The results were not good news to Springfield City Leaders.



Railroaded: A Eulogy for Public Input by Robert M. Brantley | 5 comments (5 topical, 0 hidden)

Display: Sort: